San Patricio

The Chieftains / Ry Cooder

  • AllMusic Rating
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

San Patricio Review

by Thom Jurek

To delve into history is to reach into mystery. Music is a time-honored method for investigating both. The Chieftains' Paddy Moloney has been obsessed with the historical account of the San Patricios, a band of immigrant Irish soldiers who deserted the American Army during the Mexican-American War in 1846 to fight for the other side, against the Manifest Destiny ideology of James Polk's America. Moloney’s Chieftains and co-producer Ry Cooder decided to try to tell it musically. The result brings this fascinatingly complex tale to life in the modern world and examines issues of discrimination, conscience, and empire.

The knowledge of Argentinian radio programmer Guadalupe Jolicouer pointed Moloney to traditional Mexican sources -- canciones, sons, norteños, rancheras, boleros, and polkas from the period. Moloney sorted them. He then selected, arranged, and added music he knew from the period that echoed the Irish sources. He and Cooder rounded up the numerous players, instruments, and locales necessary. Mexican performers such as los Tigres del Norte, Lila Downs, Chavela Vargas, los Folkloristas, los Camperos de Valles, and many others are featured alongside the Chieftains, Cooder, Linda Ronstadt, Galician piper Carlos Nunez, Liam Neeson, and Van Dyke Parks. Sessions were taped in Mexico, Spain, Los Angeles, New York, and Dublin. Sung in Spanish and English, the collection illumines the San Patricios’ chapter in Irish history, which was considered shameful until recently -- though in Mexico they’ve always been regarded as heroes. Through utterly compelling and ingenious musical preservation and invention, the album asks questions about commonalities between cultures; it offers evidence that history, when told personally enough, reflects shared experiences across territorial and chronological lines, and stands outside any “official” narrative, mirroring back to listeners what they can feel empathy for and sympathize with.

While this album sounds like the Chieftains playing in fusion mode, it is so much more ambitious than anything they’ve attempted before. Some of the music here is contemporary, though much of it is over a century old; yet it reaches past its settings into the present day, telling of the indelibly rich meeting of two cultures oppressed by a third. It’s full of gorgeous songs of heroism, love, tragedy, and loss. San Patricio's songs are sung passionately, without artifice, they're played expertly. The album may jar some listeners initially, but spending a little time with it will remedy that. San Patricio, more than merely satisfying Moloney’s obsession, raises more questions about what stories lay hidden under the floorboards of history than it answers, thank goodness. Music this beautifully articulated allows cultures to talk to one another across time, space, language, and other divides.

Track Listing

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
1 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:34 Amazon
2 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:08 Amazon
3 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:32 Amazon
4 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 01:30 Amazon
5 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:05 Amazon
6 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:45 Amazon
7 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 04:47 Amazon
8 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:01 Amazon
9 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:41 Amazon
10 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 04:11 Amazon
11 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 04:37 Amazon
12 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:30 Amazon
13 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:56 Amazon
14 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:55 Amazon
15 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:14 Amazon
16 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:25 Amazon
17 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 03:16 Amazon
18 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder 02:36 Amazon
19 The Chieftains / Ry Cooder feat: Juvenile / L.A. 05:47 Amazon
blue highlight denotes track pick