Walter Gieseking

Walter Gieseking Plays Brahms

  • AllMusic Rating
    7
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

Walter Gieseking Plays Brahms Review

by James Leonard

Walter Gieseking doesn't play anywhere near all the notes in this two-disc set of works by Brahms, Schubert, and Schumann. He's alright in the easier works, like the famous A major Intermezzo from Brahms' Opus 118, but more complex works like the same composer's Rhapsody in B minor, Op. 79/1, leave the pianist sounding overmatched. Despite these seemingly insurmountable drawbacks, Gieseking nevertheless gets beneath the skin of the music. Taken from Columbia recordings made in Zürich in 1951, his Brahms playing is soulful, lyrical, and above all melancholy -- necessary qualities for Brahms. The same can be said for Gieseking's performance of Schubert's Drei Klavierstücke recorded in London in 1956 and his performance of Schumann's Piano Sonata No. 1 recorded in Berlin in 1942. He leaves out a bunch of notes in Schubert's opening Allegro assai, and he hits many a clunker in Schumann's closing Allegro un poco Maestoso. But Schubert's soaring melodies and Schumann's yearning themes are totally compelling, and, in the final analysis, that is arguably more than enough. Urania's remastered sound is unfortunately dim and dull, but surprisingly clean and direct.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Pieces (8) for piano, Op. 76
1 Walter Gieseking 02:40 Amazon
2 Walter Gieseking 03:00 Amazon
3 Walter Gieseking 01:52 Amazon
4 Walter Gieseking 02:25 Amazon
5 Walter Gieseking 02:40 Amazon
6 Walter Gieseking 03:24 Amazon
7 Walter Gieseking 02:38 Amazon
8 Walter Gieseking 02:57 Amazon
Fantasias (7) for piano, Op. 116
9 Walter Gieseking 02:01 Amazon
10 Walter Gieseking 02:58 Amazon
11 Walter Gieseking 02:37 Amazon
12 Walter Gieseking 04:03 Amazon
13 Walter Gieseking 02:55 Amazon
14 Walter Gieseking 02:59 Amazon
15 Walter Gieseking 02:09 Amazon
Pieces (6) for piano, Op. 118
16 Walter Gieseking 01:31 Amazon
17 Walter Gieseking 05:22 Amazon
18 Walter Gieseking 02:50 Amazon
19 Walter Gieseking 02:51 Amazon
20 Walter Gieseking 03:21 Amazon
21 Walter Gieseking 04:50 Amazon
Pieces (4) for piano, Op. 119
22 Walter Gieseking 03:11 Amazon
23 Walter Gieseking 04:10 Amazon
24 Walter Gieseking 01:35 Amazon
25 Walter Gieseking 03:53 Amazon
blue highlight denotes track pick