My Bloody Valentine became a popular name to drop (or influence to have) by 2004, proving to be one of the more enduring alternative bands in history. Their brand of noisy, feedback-laden indie rock -- dubbed shoegazing at the time, though it's a term rarely applied to contemporary artists doing the same thing -- inspired an entire generation of musicians who wanted to create something both arty and dark. If it seems a little curious that nearly every review of Whirlaway's Pompano -- including the one you're reading -- starts with a mention of My Bloody Valentine, it's because, for better or worse, Whirlaway rips an awful lot of MBV's attributes. The ten songs that compose Pompano are drenched in drone-y feedback and sport off-tuned guitars, and like many modern feedback-laden bands (B.R.M.C., for example), they also sound strangely hollow. There are some pretty good moments here -- "Walkthrough" sounds like an early-'90s Blur B-side, and "Strangeplanes" is a good driving punk tune, but very few of this sticks on repeat listens. If imitation is the highest form of flattery, My Bloody Valentine have a lot to be proud of. But Whirlaway have some work to do if they're going to be remembered as anything other than copycats.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by Jason Damas