Castle Essential's pairing of the Humblebums' two albums, The New Humblebums and Open Up the Door, not only is the defintive retrospective and introduction to the little-known Scottish folk-pop group, but also captures the emerging talents of Billy Connolly and Gerry Rafferty. Before he became a comedian/actor, Connolly was a modest singer/songwriter, drawing from folk as well as blues, jazz, country and bluegrass. His pleasant, catchy tunes dominate the first album, and he has a several selections on the second as well, but by that time, Rafferty had joined as a replacement for Tam Harvey. Rafferty worked in the same vein as Connolly, but he was more inspired, and his contributions here are quite impressive, ranging from hooky folk-pop to brooding, introspective ballads. His songs are very good, ranking among his best, and their presence makes this two-fer worthwhile for fans of his solo work and Stealer's Wheel. Of course, any curious Connolly fan will find this fascinating as well.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by Stephen Thomas Erlewine