Josie Cotton suffers the curse of the one-hit wonder whose song wasn't that big a hit; "Johnny, Are You Queer?" might have been a smash on alternative radio if there had been such a thing in 1981, but outside of Los Angeles she was just another new wave novelty act whose act didn't play in the Midwest. Cotton is thankfully still making music 25 years later, and the results are intelligent, witty, and imaginative in ways her 15 minutes of sorta-fame would not lead you to expect. Built around darkly atmospheric keyboard patterns, echoing guitars, and off-kilter samples, Movie Disaster Music suggests a Jon Brion production gone film noir, and even the relatively upbeat numbers (like the banjo-infused "Looking for Elvis") carry a sinister undercurrent that's as troubling yet warming as a good shot of laudanum. While the production (which Cotton had a hand in on six of the 11 tracks) sets the mood of the album, Cotton's vocals put it over, and she's gained a wealth of skill and confidence in her years away from the spotlight; these performances use dynamics and nuance as much as sheer lung power to get their message across, and Cotton is a chanteuse of no small ability here. The title Movie Disaster Music fits these 11 songs like a velvet glove cast in iron; anxiety rarely sounded as inviting or as enjoyable as it does on this album, and like Aimee Mann's Whatever, it confirms Josie Cotton as a major talent who has far more to offer than her checkered past would suggest.
AllMusic Review by Mark Deming