Samuel Feinberg

J.S. Bach: Well Tempered Clavier

  • AllMusic Rating
    9
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

J.S. Bach: Well Tempered Clavier Review

by James Manheim

Few historical reissues from Russia have achieved international distribution. Western countries benefited from performances by Russian stars over the years of dictatorship, but what a treasure trove of recordings must await from artists who were not well known outside the Soviet Union! This Russian reissue gives an idea; it consists of a complete Bach Well-Tempered Clavier, Books 1 and 2, as performed between 1958 and 1961 by Samuel Feinberg, a professor at the Moscow Conservatory. Feinberg died the year after this set was finished, and he first played the Well-Tempered Clavier (in its three-hours-plus entirety!) in 1911, for his Conservatory graduation recital. Captured here, therefore, are some impressions of Bach with links to the post-Romantic era in Russia, before the terrors of war and collectivization. As a historical document, this is an invaluable release. The black-and-white photos of the artist (and his students) are illuminating in themselves.

And as an artistic statement, the album is fascinating. It's hard to think of a Bach performance quite like it. The extensive use of the pedal and the free treatment of tempo were staples of the ways in which pianists of a century ago learned to play Bach, but Feinberg's interpretations go beyond those features. His touchstone seems to have been a statement by pianist and composer Anton Rubinstein, quoted in some wonderful original liner notes by Feinberg himself: "You can find here," the great virtuoso wrote of the WTC, "fugues of the religious, heroic, melancholic, solemn, pitiful, humoristic, pastoral, and dramatic character; there is only one thing in which they are alike -- their beauty." The hallmark of Feinberg's interpretation, which is extreme but consistently thought-out and executed, is his individuation of Bach's preludes and fugues, accomplished through articulation more than anything else. You may have heard pedaled Bach, Chopin-like Bach, the go-like-the-freezing-wind Bach of Glenn Gould, but you've never heard lines jump out of the texture as they do here, always playing a part in a coherent plan for each piece.

Sound ranges from acceptable to poor, and in some of the performances (sample those in the first half of the first disc) the top register of the piano has a dull metallic clang that reminds one of the smaller gongs in a Javanese gamelan orchestra. But it doesn't matter -- all this does is emphasize the contrasts and distinctness of line that is built into Feinberg's performances. More than a curiosity, this recording is essential listening for the new breed of pianists who are ignoring current fashion and playing the Baroque masterworks on their instrument -- these performers tend to say they never try to make the piano sound like a harpsichord, and a piano has rarely sounded less like a harpsichord than it does here.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
The Well-Tempered Clavier (24), collection of preludes & fugues, Book I, BWV 846-869 (BC L80-103)
1 Samuel Feinberg 02:31 Amazon
2 Samuel Feinberg 02:11 Amazon
3 Samuel Feinberg 01:26 Amazon
4 Samuel Feinberg 01:30 Amazon
5 Samuel Feinberg 01:26 Amazon
6 Samuel Feinberg 02:00 Amazon
7 Samuel Feinberg 02:49 Amazon
8 Samuel Feinberg 04:57 Amazon
9 Samuel Feinberg 01:11 Amazon
10 Samuel Feinberg 01:53 Amazon
11 Samuel Feinberg 01:25 Amazon
12 Samuel Feinberg 02:14 Amazon
13 Samuel Feinberg 03:06 Amazon
14 Samuel Feinberg 01:33 Amazon
15 Samuel Feinberg 04:17 Amazon
16 Samuel Feinberg 04:53 Amazon
17 Samuel Feinberg 01:12 Amazon
18 Samuel Feinberg 01:03 Amazon
19 Samuel Feinberg 02:29 Amazon
20 Samuel Feinberg 01:09 Amazon
21 Samuel Feinberg 01:01 Amazon
22 Samuel Feinberg 01:05 Amazon
23 Samuel Feinberg 01:52 Amazon
24 Samuel Feinberg 05:18 Amazon
25 Samuel Feinberg 01:16 Amazon
26 Samuel Feinberg 01:46 Amazon
27 Samuel Feinberg 01:01 Amazon
28 Samuel Feinberg 03:50 Amazon
29 Samuel Feinberg 00:46 Amazon
30 Samuel Feinberg 02:25 Amazon
31 Samuel Feinberg 01:51 Amazon
32 Samuel Feinberg 02:52 Amazon
33 Samuel Feinberg 01:17 Amazon
34 Samuel Feinberg 02:43 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 2

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
The Well-Tempered Clavier (24), collection of preludes & fugues, Book I, BWV 846-869 (BC L80-103)
1 Samuel Feinberg 01:18 Amazon
2 Samuel Feinberg 02:24 Amazon
3 Samuel Feinberg 00:56 Amazon
4 Samuel Feinberg 01:58 Amazon
5 Samuel Feinberg 01:08 Amazon
6 Samuel Feinberg 04:15 Amazon
7 Samuel Feinberg 01:11 Amazon
8 Samuel Feinberg 01:22 Amazon
9 Samuel Feinberg 02:35 Amazon
10 Samuel Feinberg 03:06 Amazon
11 Samuel Feinberg 01:03 Amazon
12 Samuel Feinberg 02:13 Amazon
13 Samuel Feinberg 04:41 Amazon
14 Samuel Feinberg 05:33 Amazon
The Well-Tempered Clavier (24), collection of preludes & fugues, Book II, BWV 870-893 (BC L104-127)
15 Samuel Feinberg 02:38 Amazon
16 Samuel Feinberg 01:26 Amazon
17 Samuel Feinberg 01:04 Amazon
18 Samuel Feinberg 02:17 Amazon
19 Samuel Feinberg 01:19 Amazon
20 Samuel Feinberg 01:35 Amazon
21 Samuel Feinberg 05:10 Amazon
22 Samuel Feinberg 01:46 Amazon
23 Samuel Feinberg 02:24 Amazon
24 Samuel Feinberg 02:14 Amazon
25 Samuel Feinberg 01:27 Amazon
26 Samuel Feinberg 01:56 Amazon
27 Samuel Feinberg 02:13 Amazon
28 Samuel Feinberg 01:46 Amazon
29 Samuel Feinberg 02:01 Amazon
30 Samuel Feinberg 04:20 Amazon
31 Samuel Feinberg 02:03 Amazon
32 Samuel Feinberg 03:34 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 3

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
The Well-Tempered Clavier (24), collection of preludes & fugues, Book II, BWV 870-893 (BC L104-127)
1 Samuel Feinberg 01:33 Amazon
2 Samuel Feinberg 02:41 Amazon
3 Samuel Feinberg 02:26 Amazon
4 Samuel Feinberg 01:25 Amazon
5 Samuel Feinberg 01:34 Amazon
6 Samuel Feinberg 01:46 Amazon
7 Samuel Feinberg 03:49 Amazon
8 Samuel Feinberg 01:49 Amazon
9 Samuel Feinberg 03:03 Amazon
10 Samuel Feinberg 04:02 Amazon
11 Samuel Feinberg 01:05 Amazon
12 Samuel Feinberg 01:05 Amazon
13 Samuel Feinberg 03:19 Amazon
14 Samuel Feinberg 02:31 Amazon
15 Samuel Feinberg 04:12 Amazon
16 Samuel Feinberg 03:42 Amazon
17 Samuel Feinberg 01:40 Amazon
18 Samuel Feinberg 04:14 Amazon
19 Samuel Feinberg 01:16 Amazon
20 Samuel Feinberg 01:07 Amazon
21 Samuel Feinberg 02:34 Amazon
22 Samuel Feinberg 01:36 Amazon
23 Samuel Feinberg 02:17 Amazon
24 Samuel Feinberg 02:02 Amazon
25 Samuel Feinberg 02:54 Amazon
26 Samuel Feinberg 03:22 Amazon
27 Samuel Feinberg 01:32 Amazon
28 Samuel Feinberg 04:04 Amazon
29 Samuel Feinberg 02:02 Amazon
30 Samuel Feinberg 01:22 Amazon
blue highlight denotes track pick