Elisabeth Ziegler

György Ligeti: Le Grand Macabre

  • AllMusic Rating
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by Uncle Dave Lewis

György Ligeti's only opera, Le Grand Macabre, was initially suggested by film and theater director Göran Gentele who was in 1965 director of the Stockholm Opera. Ligeti and librettist Michael Meschke adapted Belgian author Michel van Ghelderode's 1934 play La balade du grande macabre into the needed libretto and finished the opera in a mere six years. The Wergo CD of the work (there are two; the other is led by Esa-Pekka Salonen on Sony) is not of the first production of Le Grand Macabre but the second, held in the Grossen Konzerthaussaal in Vienna in 1987 under the direction of Elgar Howarth.

Le Grand Macabre is a mega-bizarre opera that is part post-modern avant-garde and part Marx Brothers; a mad escapade that calls for sirens, auto horns, and singers who are able to behave like loons, and yet sing up into the stratosphere if necessary. This performance is live and once in awhile you can hear a titter of laughter from the audience. Le Grand Macabre IS funny -- thankfully there is a thick German-English libretto included with the set, so one need not fuss that any of the humor (or horror -- there's a considerable amount of that also) will be missed. A thinner booklet found inside the clamshell case contains the liner notes and track listings. This Grossen Konzerthaussaal performance is as good as can be hoped for in such a difficult work, but that does not mean the music itself is "difficult." Le Grand Macabre isn't tuneful -- it's written in a highly complex, late twentieth century idiom, but with action of the play to hang the music onto it is fairly easy to follow, and is nonetheless very entertaining.

Le Grand Macabre isn't staged with much frequency, as it appears to be a rather expensive production. A video or DVD would be the best way, outside the concert hall, to experience it, but in the lack of such a product this rather pricey two-disc set will have to do. If the listener is interested in contemporary European opera after 1950 this should be the first place to go. Wergo's live recording is of excellent quality, but could stand to be a little louder than it is.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Le Grand Macabre, opera
1 Elisabeth Ziegler 01:09 Amazon
2 Elisabeth Ziegler 06:36 Amazon
3 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:47 Amazon
4 Elisabeth Ziegler 05:02 Amazon
5 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:37 Amazon
6 Elisabeth Ziegler 00:57 Amazon
7 Elisabeth Ziegler 03:35 Amazon
8 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:44 Amazon
9 Elisabeth Ziegler 05:54 Amazon
10 Elisabeth Ziegler 06:13 Amazon
11 Elisabeth Ziegler 03:46 Amazon
12 Elisabeth Ziegler 01:06 Amazon
13 Elisabeth Ziegler 05:52 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 2

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Le Grand Macabre, opera
1 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:04
2 Elisabeth Ziegler 03:06
3 Elisabeth Ziegler 03:33
4 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:40
5 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:51
6 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:46
7 Elisabeth Ziegler 01:11
8 Elisabeth Ziegler 08:28
9 Elisabeth Ziegler 13:05
10 Elisabeth Ziegler 01:02
11 Elisabeth Ziegler 02:18
12 Elisabeth Ziegler 04:06
13 Elisabeth Ziegler 06:33
blue highlight denotes track pick