It is hard to believe that this concert was a first for this trio. Programmed at the Festival International de Musique Actuelle de Victoriaville, the premiere headlined the 2002 edition of the event. Both organizers and spectators were probably hoping for something more impressive and jaw-dropping. Cecil Taylor, Bill Dixon, and Tony Oxley gave a short performance (50 minutes, all included on this untitled CD), a good one -- classy and correct -- but there was no revelation that evening. Critics who usually complain that Taylor sounds like he is paid by the note might point out that this time he lacked stamina or involvement (there's no pleasing critics). The fact is that both Taylor and Oxley sound like they open up their playing, deliberately refraining from engaging in a race up the density ladder, all in order to leave room for Dixon's sparse, echo-drenched punctuations. Despite their efforts, the trumpeter does not feel quite at ease. Less talkative than usual, he plays little and contributes even less to the group improvisation. All that being said, this CD (released very quickly by Victo's standards) remains an interesting listen, a good average session. Fans of any or all of these living legends will not want to pass it up, especially since it was recorded by the talented engineers at Radio-Canada. It just proves that sometimes the sum of a group does not equal the value of its parts.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by François Couture