Although one could be forgiven for assuming Porter to be an alternative country band, both from their band name and their rustic-looking album cover art, they actually happen to produce an eclectic mélange of sounds ranging from Afro-pop and Spanish tinges to pedestrian jazz and funk. As usual, the delicate equation that is required to make those influences not turn into frustratingly elastic and self-important experimentation is constantly is danger of falling out of balance, leaving the band to tread the line between radio-friendly Dave Matthews Band-fare and more serious genre exercises. Lead vocalist Peter Fand isn't aided by the fact that he possesses a pleasant, if singularly indistinct singing voice, just as guitarist Tom Rossi shows himself a more than adequate musician who doesn't play with much personality. Even as the smooth jazz/pop of "A Change in the Weather" could draw reasonable comparisons to Harry Connick, Jr., and the faux-white bread crooning of profanities provide a moment of cheap humor if nothing else, most of Whiskey Hill smacks of the band members having too much talent to know which ways to most effectively channel their ambitions.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by Matt Fink