Wagner: Tristan und Isolde

Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler

  • AllMusic Rating
    10
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

Wagner: Tristan und Isolde Review

by Stephen Eddins

Wilhelm Furtwängler's 1952 EMI recording of Tristan und Isolde with the Philharmonia Orchestra is a gold standard among recordings of the opera. The integrality of his vision and his command of the opera's large structural elements make this a version that is widely admired by listeners who love the opera. Although his reading is never rushed, and is notable for its moments of sensuous languor, for the most part, the opera has rarely sounded so impetuously and freshly imagined. The opening of the Prelude is a marvel; its primal rawness perfectly sets the stage for the searing drama. Isolde's Act I monologue and Marke's Act II monologue lack energy and are Furtwängler's least effective moments, but they are more than compensated for by the blazing intensity of the "Love Duet," the anguish of Tristan's yearning in the third act, and the ecstatic resolution of the" Liebestod." Kirsten Flagstad made the recording late in her career, when she was in her late 50s, and while her voice doesn't have the youthful bloom ideal for Isolde, her vulnerability and tenderness, her subtle musicality, and the immense warmth and dignity of her exceptional voice make her an Isolde for the ages. Ludwig Suthaus never had the weight of a heldentenor of the first water, but his is an entirely respectable Tristan, fully capable of negotiating the staggering demands of the role, and his characterization is musically intelligent and nuanced. Blanche Thebom's Brangäne is radiant, and her warning in Act II is one of the highlights of the recording. The young Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau is a vocally powerful Kurwenal, and his characterization is sharply etched. Josef Greindl sounds underpowered as King Marke, and comes across as more pathetic than really grief-stricken. The members of the Philharmonia Orchestra, who beautifully follow Furtwängler's lead in their impassioned playing, are also stars of the performance. The variety of colors they produce, from the practically Medieval sound of the opening notes of the Prelude to the lushly Romantic passion and warmth of the second act, is remarkable. The sound is vintage, but is full, clear, and vivid. The general high level of the performance, particularly the outstanding work of Flagstad, Furtwängler, and the Philharmonia Orchestra, make this a version of the opera that should be of strong interest to any Wagnerian.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Tristan und Isolde
1 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 11:01 Amazon
2 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:18 Amazon
3 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:51 Amazon
4 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:17 Amazon
5 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 00:49 Amazon
6 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:25 Amazon
7 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:08 Amazon
8 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:41 Amazon
9 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:02 Amazon
10 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:24 Amazon
11 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:10 Amazon
12 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:39 Amazon
13 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:51 Amazon
14 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:09 Amazon
15 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:22 Amazon
16 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:04 Amazon
17 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:11 Amazon
18 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:18 Amazon
19 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:48 Amazon
20 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:00 Amazon
21 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:48 Amazon
22 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:17 Amazon
23 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:19 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 2

Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Tristan und Isolde
1 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:42 Amazon
2 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:26 Amazon
3 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:36 Amazon
4 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:47 Amazon
5 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:47 Amazon
6 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:41 Amazon
7 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:38 Amazon
8 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:00 Amazon
9 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:50 Amazon
10 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:10 Amazon
11 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:15 Amazon
12 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:13 Amazon
13 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:34 Amazon
14 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:27 Amazon
15 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:50 Amazon
16 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:40 Amazon
17 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:26 Amazon
18 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:36 Amazon
19 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 05:41 Amazon
20 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:29 Amazon
21 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:20 Amazon
22 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:55 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 3

Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Tristan und Isolde
1 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:30 Amazon
2 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:24 Amazon
3 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:35 Amazon
4 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:58 Amazon
5 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:59 Amazon
6 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:57 Amazon
7 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:47 Amazon
8 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:13 Amazon
9 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:55 Amazon
10 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:52 Amazon
11 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:08 Amazon
12 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:35 Amazon
13 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:23 Amazon
14 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:04 Amazon
15 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:17 Amazon
16 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:17 Amazon
17 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:09 Amazon
18 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:40 Amazon
19 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:01 Amazon
20 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:30 Amazon

Track Listing - Disc 4

Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
Tristan und Isolde
1 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:54 Amazon
2 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:50 Amazon
3 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:47 Amazon
4 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:20 Amazon
5 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:06 Amazon
6 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:28 Amazon
7 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:14 Amazon
8 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:43 Amazon
9 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:27 Amazon
10 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:49 Amazon
11 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 02:21 Amazon
12 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:04 Amazon
13 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 04:21 Amazon
14 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 01:56 Amazon
15 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:27 Amazon
16 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:43 Amazon
17 Kirsten Flagstad / Wilhelm Furtwängler 03:29 Amazon
blue highlight denotes track pick