Courtney Barnett specializes in miniatures, which is why her 2015 debut, Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit, was such a wonder: with barbed words and gnarled guitars, she made everyday minutiae seem compelling. Three years in the making -- it was delayed in part due to a 2017 collaboration with Kurt Vile -- the 2018 sequel, Tell Me How You Really Feel, plays like the flip image of its predecessor. What once was captivating now feels indifferent, delivered with a shrug instead of a snarl. Everything about Tell Me How You Really Feel seems muted, whether it's the grungy stomp of Barnett and her band -- a group that remains steadfastly and proudly stuck in the glory days of '90s alt-rock -- or her words, which now seem to meander to a point instead of cutting to the quick. As she's a good craftswoman, the songs are by and large sturdy, but that talent also cuts against the success of Tell Me How You Really Feel: when they're matched with the appealing yet incurious performances, everything feels a bit too cozy. Sometimes, a hook or a clever line cuts through the amiable haze -- and "Charity," with its chorus of "so subservient I make myself sick," manages to blend both -- but Tell Me How You Really Feel isn't an album of moments, it's a collection that sustains a mood: a mood that's ragged and slack, but too dulled to charm.
Tell Me How You Really Feel
Courtney Barnett
Share on
Tell Me How You Really Feel Review
by Stephen Thomas Erlewine
Track Listing
Title/Composer | Performer | Time | Stream | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Courtney Barnett | 04:48 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
2 | Courtney Barnett | 04:41 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
3 | Courtney Barnett | 04:10 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
4 | Courtney Barnett | 03:58 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
5 | Courtney Barnett | 03:14 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
6 | Courtney Barnett | 01:50 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
7 | Courtney Barnett | 02:48 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
8 | Courtney Barnett | 03:02 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
9 | Courtney Barnett | 04:01 | SpotifyAmazon | |||
10 | Courtney Barnett | 04:44 | SpotifyAmazon |