Simon Keenlyside / David Charles Abell / BBC Concert Orchestra / Scarlett Strallen

Something's Gotta Give

  • AllMusic Rating
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by

American musicals have been performed in London for pretty much as long as there has been such a thing, yet British albums of Broadway songs are considerably rarer than those from the U.S., and usually they tend toward the international sort of spectacle production. Thus it is all the more surprising that British baritone Simon Keenlyside, not previously known for crossover material, has nailed the thing on his first time out. Several factors work in his favor. He does not affect an American accent (which many of these songs wouldn't have been sung in originally), but he finds a natural melodic flow and articulates the words beautifully. Reviewing the Situation, from Oliver!, is especially interesting: Keenlyside effectively depicts an American put-on of a British accent. He finds an ideal collaborator in soprano Scarlett Strallen, who seems to come at the music from the theatrical side and makes an ideal foil. Keenlyside chooses a fine program of familiar-but-not-overdone numbers, and he benefits from excellent support from the BBC Concert Orchestra under David Charles Abell, who uses sparse arrangements based on original pit-orchestra versions. The best thing of all, though, is an X factor based on the heft Keenlyside gives the material. He sings a couple of numbers from Carousel, the most serious and problematical of all the musicals, and he gets to the human spirit in something as light as Rodgers' It Might as Well Be Spring. An ideal gift item for those who enjoy the operatic/musical theater boundary line.

Track Listing

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time Stream
My Fair Lady
1 3:21
Kiss Me, Kate
2 2:35
Gay Divorce
3 4:03
4 4:16
5 4:04
6 6:09
Very Warm for May
7 3:36
8 8:07
Something's Gotta Give
9 7:09
10 4:23
State Fair
11 4:00
The Girl Next Door
12 3:40
Romance on the High Seas
13 2:55
14 2:48
Fiddler on the Roof
15 5:40
16 8:40 Amazon
blue highlight denotes track pick