Liza Minnelli

Millennium Edition

  • AllMusic Rating
    7
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by

The Liza Minnelli number in Universal Germany's Millennium Edition series of single-CD compilations is a straight reissue of the 1973 double-LP The Liza Minnelli Foursider. By whatever name or format, the collection is a condensation of Minnelli's five-year sojourn at A&M Records, 1968-1972, drawn from the studio albums Liza Minnelli (1968), Come Saturday Morning (April 1970), New Feelin' (December 1970), and Live at the Olympia (1972). The first side of the first disc in the original LP package (tracks one-five on the CD version) reduces Live at the Olympia to about eighteen-and-a-half minutes, beginning with the "Introduction" opening medley and ending with the closing number, "Cabaret," the title song from Minnelli's then most recently released film, which became a signature song for her. Like the other record labels that handled the singer (Capitol came before, Columbia and others followed), A&M didn't know quite what to do with her. Although only in her early to mid-twenties, she did not fit comfortably in the rock world, but the market for middle-of-the-road performers was diminishing quickly. The confusion can be experienced at the outset of this collection in that "Introduction," which, incredibly, includes excerpts of both "Consider Yourself" from the British musical Oliver! and the Doors' "Hello, I Love You." Minnelli was a much better fit for the former, but it was songs like that latter that were selling records in the late '60s and early '70s. Live at the Olympia was actually the best of the A&M albums since it displayed Minnelli's talents as a stage performer and presaged the essentially similar but much more successful Liza with a "Z" album that followed on Columbia only a few months later. (Here, the song "Liza with a 'Z'" is sung in French, a nod to the audience at the Olympia in Paris.) The three studio albums, which provide the material for the second, third, and fourth sides of Foursider (tracks six-19 on the CD) contain a mixture of pre- rock standards ("My Mammy," "Nevertheless I'm in Love with You,") and covers of soft rock hits of the era (Sonny & Cher's "You'd Better Sit Down, Kids," John Denver's [by way of Peter, Paul & Mary] "Leavin' on a Jet Plane"), as well as "Come Saturday Morning," the theme song for Minnelli's film The Sterile Cuckoo. The strangest tracks come from New Feelin', an album that tried to split the difference in marketing Minnelli by recording pre-rock standards in funky soul-rock arrangements à la Aretha Franklin or Dusty Springfield. The bizarre results can be heard here in Minnelli's renditions of "Come Rain or Come Shine," "Lazy Bones," "The Man I Love," and "God Bless the Child," as well, equally unfortunately, as another of her signature songs, "Maybe This Time," a tune she had introduced earlier and that was later interpolated into the movie version of Cabaret. Under the title Foursider, this collection is about as good a sampler as could be assembled from the limited resources available, and it does feature some of the songs with which Minnelli is most identified, albeit not in ideal versions. Calling the same collection Millennium Edition, however, implies that it is a more comprehensive compilation than it really is.

blue highlight denotes track pick