Herbert von Karajan

Karajan: Sibelius, 1976-1981

  • AllMusic Rating
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by

Longtime collectors of Herbert von Karajan's EMI recordings with the Berlin Philharmonic may already own many of these Sibelius performances on LP or CD, though budget-conscious newcomers should be aware of a few problems in this reissue in Warner Classics' official remastered edition. First, and most importantly, this is not a complete cycle of Sibelius' symphonies, since Karajan never recorded the Third, and the Seventh was recorded for Deutsche Grammophon in 1967, falling outside the period covered by this set (1976-1981). For a complete set of the symphonies (though without the tone poems that are included here), the DG triple CD reissue with recordings by Karajan and Okko Kamu is a better substitute. Second, the reproduction of this compilation is uneven, with the best all-digital sound presented on the first disc (Symphonies No. 1 & No. 6), and the weakest remastering of the analog masters on the third CD (Symphonies No. 4 & No. 5), which offers fairly thin textures at soft dynamics and harsh sonorities at climaxes. Third, Karajan's reputation for interpreting Sibelius -- based in part on a generous endorsement from the aging composer in the 1950s, and also on the conductor's critically praised recordings in the 1960s -- is highest among his loyal fans, but it is not universal. The nearly contemporary recordings by Colin Davis and the Boston Symphony Orchestra on Decca are bona-fide classics, and the superb SACD cycle by Osmo Vänskä and the Lahti Symphony Orchestra on BIS is another set worth trying.

blue highlight denotes track pick