Big Dismal is a Florida-based quartet with a straightforward post-grunge sound drawing equally from the formulaic rock of Creed and 3 Doors Down, as well as the Goo Goo Dolls and the band's strong Christian faith. Believe, their debut for Wind-Up, is heavy on the overly emotive vocals of vocalist Eric Durrance, who also contributes a ringing acoustic guitar to many of the album's ten tracks. But while the record will certainly appeal to those who like their post-grunge with a Christian bent, it's unclear why music with a message needs to be so incredibly bland. Believe is as one-dimensional as they come, with the charming chorus harmonies of Evanescence's Amy Lee on "Missing You" becoming the album's only left-hand turn. The formula of a chugging alt-metal number followed by an equally chugging yet jangly song tires after the first eight minutes of the album. By the time the good-timing melody of "Too Pretty" arrives, it's acceptable to overlook the song's glaring clichés, if only to lift something else on Believe above the average.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by Johnny Loftus