András Schiff

Beethoven: Diabelli-Variationen

  • AllMusic Rating
    9
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by

ECM New Series is better known for its documentation of contemporary works, but the music of the past sometimes receives coverage when artists bring a new perspective to it. The Diabelli Variations, Op. 120; the Sonata No. 32 in C minor, Op. 111; and the Six Bagatelles, Op. 126, are among the most original and intellectually stimulating works Ludwig van Beethoven composed for the piano, and the sophisticated interpretations of András Schiff are especially worthwhile for their insights into authentic performance practice and reception. Here, Schiff gives the listener options between a relatively modern sounding version of the Diabelli Variations and a period interpretation, without favoring one or the other. On the first CD he plays the Sonata and the Diabelli Variations on a Bechstein piano from 1921, though with minimal pedaling and a restrained execution that allows every inner voice and subtle dynamic to be appreciated. While this piano is not as hard or bright sounding as a modern Steinway, it is familiar to modern ears and most listeners will readily accept it. On the second CD, Schiff plays the Diabelli Variations, along with the Six Bagatelles, on a smaller sounding Franz Brodmann fortepiano, an original instrument from around 1820, Beethoven's time period. While it sometimes sounds tinnier, the fortepiano is in wonderful condition, and by Schiff's own testimony, it "sounds fresher, bolder, and infinitely more subtle." This side-by-side demonstration allows comparisons between the two instruments, and to consider other differences. One need not choose one recording over the other, but Schiff's exceptional performances would certainly inform such a decision, if one had to be made.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time
Sonate No. 32 in c-Moll, Op. 111
1 8:54
2 17:30
Diabelli-Variationen, Op. 120
3 0:45
4 1:38
5 0:48
6 1:20
7 0:59
8 0:58
9 1:35
10 1:08
11 1:28
12 1:52
13 0:41
14 1:09
15 1:00
16 1:11
17 3:34
18 0:37
19 1:02
20 1:03
21 1:35
22 0:58
23 1:43
24 1:09
25 0:38
26 0:55
27 2:32
28 0:52
29 1:28
30 1:01
31 1:05
32 1:09
33 1:46
34 4:31
35 2:53
36 4:12

Track Listing - Disc 2

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time
Diabelli-Variationen, Op. 120
1 0:48
2 1:39
3 0:54
4 1:25
5 1:01
6 0:59
7 1:40
8 1:13
9 1:31
10 1:56
11 0:44
12 1:07
13 1:05
14 1:12
15 3:31
16 0:39
17 1:02
18 1:09
19 1:40
20 0:59
21 1:49
22 1:10
23 0:43
24 0:58
25 2:34
26 0:53
27 1:29
28 1:04
29 1:12
30 1:11
31 1:57
32 4:30
33 3:01
34 4:17
Sechs Bagatellen, Op. 126
35 2:54
36 2:56
37 2:23
38 3:44
39 2:16
40 4:01
blue highlight denotes track pick