Math and Physics Club are an indie pop group that formed in Seattle in 2004, when guitarist James Werle and vocalist Charles Bert, who had been collaborating on various recordings up until that point, started working with drummer Kevin Emerson, violinist Saundrah Humphrey, and bassist Ethan Jones. Sounding something like a cross between the Smiths, the Field Mice, and Belle and Sebastian, MAPC were snapped up by Matinée by the end of the year. Their debut EP on that label, Weekends Away, came out in February 2005; the disc enjoyed quite a bit of critical buzz, and was in regular rotation on Seattle's KEXP that year. Proving that they were anything if not prolific, MAPC had another EP, Movie Ending Romance, out on Matinée by the time summer rolled around. Their self-titled debut full-length, produced by Kevin Suggs, came out a little over a year later, and they followed it up with a modest East Coast tour. Having taken a quick breather at the beginning of the year, MAPC returned with another Matinée EP, Baby I'm Yours, in the summer of 2007.
Emerson left the band (though Emerson stuck around to play drums on the next album). I Shouldn't Look as Good as I Do was released in early summer 2010. The group toured the U.K. in 2011, then headed to the Dub Narcotic Studio to work on its next record. Produced by the band's longtime bassist Jones and Bob Schwenkler, Our Hearts Beat Out Loud was released by Matinée in late 2013. That same year they released a single, "Long Drag," and in 2014 were on a split single with former Lucksmiths member Mark Monnone. After that the band took a bit of a break, with Bert forming Unlikely Friends with BOAT's D. Crane and Chris McFarlane, who had spent time as MAPC's drummer at one point. They released an album, Solid Gold Cowboys, in 2015. By this time Math and Physics Club were working on new songs, one of which ("Coastal California, 1985") ended up on 2016's In This Together, a collection of early songs from the EPs, non-LP songs, and unreleased tracks issued jointly by Matinée and Fika Recordings.