Essentially, Juvenilia is the single for "Jealousy," one of the more pop-oriented tracks on Liz Phair's second album, Whip-Smart. In order to make the single more enticing for the singer/songwriter's fans, five tracks from her legendary Girlysound tapes were included, marking the first official release of this material. Arriving well after the initial media onslaught of Phair's debut, Exile in Guyville -- which included numerous references to the home-recorded tapes -- the Girlysound sessions might sound a bit disappointing because they offer no new insights into Phair's songwriting. If anything, the selected songs accentuate her tendency to be cloying and cute. Not only do the repeated "f*cks" begin to sound like a gimmick, she appropriates Iggy Pop's "Funtime" on "South Dakota" for no apparent reason than to demonstrate her cleverness. Before the Girlysound songs, Phair runs through a limp version of the Vapors' new wave classic "Turning Japanese" with Material Issue and hands in "Animal Girl," an unremarkable new piano ballad.
Share this page
AllMusic Review by Stephen Thomas Erlewine