Marie-Nicole Lemieux / Alan Curtis

Handel: Giulio Cesare

  • AllMusic Rating
    9
  • User Ratings (0)
  • Your Rating

AllMusic Review by

This recording of Handel's big opera about Caesar and Cleopatra features an American conductor and a European orchestra, and a supporting cast from all over. But the real stars, and reasons enough for purchase on their own, are a pair of French Canadians. Marie-Nicole Lemieux proceeds without stress in the difficult role of Caesar, originally written for the castrato Senesino and a beast of a challenge for other singers, male or female, ever since. Lemieux's job is made all the more difficult by conductor Alan Curtis' fast tempi, which he justifies fairly convincingly in a booklet note. Perhaps even more seductive for the buyer is soprano Karina Gauvin as Cleopatra. Gauvin has been called the Renée Fleming of Baroque music, to which one might object that Renée Fleming is the Renée Fleming of Baroque music. But Gauvin can stand the comparison. Sample the aria "Se pietà di me non senti," CD 2, track 25, for an instance of the creamy power that is gaining Gauvin a legion of followers that just a few Baroque specialists have matched. The opera is a monster even at Curtis' fast clip, and even as he varies the configuration of his continuo group in what generally can be called a state-of-the-art performance. But many of the singers of the smaller roles have a fine dramatic sense, none more than countertenor Filippo Mineccia as the villainous Tolomeo. This merits strong consideration, especially for those looking for a period-instrument performance to go with the classic Beverly Sills reading.

Track Listing - Disc 1

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time
Giulio Cesare in Egitto
1 2:41
2 1:32
3 2:08
4 3:42
5 3:34
6 1:26
7 5:11
8 0:22
9 4:07
10 2:20
11 4:23
12 1:26
13 3:29
14 2:30
15 1:40
16 3:03
17 0:32
18 4:54
19 0:21
20 2:26
21 2:08
22 4:40
23 0:26
24 4:34
25 1:01
26 6:10
27 2:22
28 4:33

Track Listing - Disc 2

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time
Giulio Cesare in Egitto
1 0:32
2 7:37
3 1:47
4 0:29
5 0:22
6 0:53
7 0:16
8 5:09
9 1:20
10 7:54
11 2:02
12 1:28
13 3:02
14 0:48
15 3:15
16 1:58
17 3:29
18 0:20
19 5:18
20 0:29
21 4:01
22 3:19
23 3:14
24 0:56
25 8:42
26 1:39
27 3:35

Track Listing - Disc 3

Sample Title/Composer Performer Time
Giulio Cesare in Egitto
1 5:21
2 0:31
3 2:59
4 0:38
5 0:49
6 4:10
7 6:33
8 8:39
9 3:13
10 4:02
11 0:29
12 4:00
13 1:56
14 1:14
15 6:20
16 1:46
17 2:58
18 2:46
19 2:04
20 4:48
21 0:21
22 2:40
blue highlight denotes track pick